VoIP or Traditional Phone Lines for a Dental Office?

By Starcomm Technologies ·

For most dental offices, a VoIP phone system (phones that run over your internet connection) is the better choice today. It handles a busy front desk, several lines and after-hours messages more flexibly than traditional phone lines, and it is easier to change as the practice grows. The trade-off is that VoIP depends on your internet and your power, so it only works well with a solid connection and a plan for outages. Some offices also keep one traditional line for fax, an alarm panel or as a backup.

Below we walk through the differences in plain English so you can decide what fits your clinic.

What's the difference between VoIP and a traditional phone line?

A traditional phone line (often called a landline or analog line) is a dedicated line from the phone company into your building. Each line carries one call at a time, and features like hunt groups or voicemail are usually add-ons from the phone company or an older phone system in your back room.

VoIP stands for Voice over Internet Protocol. In simple terms, your calls travel over the internet as data, the same way email does. With a cloud-based VoIP system, the "brains" of the phone system live with the provider rather than in a box in your office. Your desk phones plug into your network, and you manage greetings, call routing and extensions through a web page or by asking your IT company.

Why do most dental offices move to VoIP?

A dental front desk is one of the busiest phone environments in a small business. Patients call to book, confirm, reschedule and ask about insurance, often all at once in the morning. VoIP tends to handle that better because:

  • More calls at once. You are not limited by how many physical lines come into the building. Adding capacity is usually a change to your plan, not a new line installation.
  • Auto-attendant. A recorded menu ("press 1 for appointments, press 2 for billing") can route calls so the right person picks up.
  • Call queues and hold messages. Callers wait in order and can hear useful information instead of a busy signal.
  • Day and night modes. Calls can switch automatically to an after-hours greeting or an emergency message on a schedule.
  • Voicemail to email. Messages can arrive in an inbox so nobody has to dial in to check them (more on privacy below).
  • Easy moves and changes. Adding a phone for a new hygienist or moving an extension to another operatory is usually quick.
  • Multiple locations. If you run more than one clinic, VoIP can connect them so staff can transfer calls between offices as if they were down the hall.
  • Softphones and mobile apps. An owner or office manager can make and take office calls from a laptop or phone app, showing the clinic's number.

Some VoIP services also offer integration with practice management software, such as showing a patient's name when they call. Support varies a lot, so check with the phone provider whether it works with the software you use, whether that is Dentrix, ABELDent, Tracker, ClearDent or something else.

When is a traditional line still the better choice?

Traditional lines are not wrong, they are just less flexible. A landline can still make sense when:

  • Your internet is unreliable and you cannot improve it at your location.
  • You rely on fax for insurance, referrals or lab work and your fax machine struggles over VoIP.
  • Your alarm panel or another device needs an analog line to call out.
  • You want a backup that works if your internet is down.

Keep in mind that phone companies have been moving customers off older copper lines in many areas, so a "traditional" line today may itself run over newer equipment. Ask your carrier how your line is actually delivered before assuming it will behave like an old landline.

What happens to VoIP phones when the internet or power goes out?

This is the most common worry, and it is a fair one. If your internet drops, cloud VoIP phones in the office stop working until it comes back. If your power goes out, your internet equipment and phones go down too, unless they are on battery backup.

The good news is that a cloud system keeps working on the provider's side, so you can plan around it:

  • Automatic forwarding. If your office phones go offline, calls can be sent to a cell phone or another location instead of ringing out.
  • Mobile apps. Staff can keep answering the clinic number from a phone app while you sort out the problem.
  • Battery backup (a UPS). A small unit can keep your modem, network switch and phones running through short power blips. Our post on whether a dental office needs a battery backup explains how this works.
  • A second internet connection. Some offices add a backup connection from a different provider, or a cellular backup, that takes over automatically.

If your internet does go down, our guide on what to do when your dental office internet goes down covers the first steps.

Does VoIP sound as good as a landline?

It can, when the network behind it is set up properly. Choppy audio, echo and dropped calls almost always come from the network, not the phones. The usual causes are:

  • An internet connection that is too slow or too busy, especially upload speed. Our post on how fast a dental office's internet needs to be helps you check.
  • No traffic priority on the router. A setting often called QoS (quality of service) tells your network to put voice calls ahead of large downloads or imaging uploads.
  • Phones on weak Wi-Fi. Desk phones should be plugged into network cabling wherever possible.
  • Old or poorly installed cabling and network switches.

With those handled, most staff and patients will not notice a difference from a landline.

What about fax, 911 and patient privacy?

Fax

Fax machines were designed for traditional lines and can be unreliable over VoIP. The common fixes are a fax adapter set up for your VoIP provider, an online fax service that sends and receives faxes as PDFs, or keeping one traditional line just for fax.

911

With VoIP, emergency services rely on the address registered with your provider rather than a fixed line. Make sure each location's address is correct with your provider, and update it if you move or add a site.

Patient privacy

Call recordings, voicemails and voicemail-to-email messages can contain personal health information, which Ontario's PHIPA covers. Ask your provider where recordings and voicemails are stored, who can access them and how long they are kept, and tell callers if you record calls. Voicemail emails should go to secure, password-protected inboxes, ideally with multi-factor sign-in. For the details of your obligations, the Information and Privacy Commissioner of Ontario has guidance for health care providers, and your college or a lawyer can advise on your specific situation.

A checklist before you switch

If you are leaning toward VoIP, work through these steps first:

  1. Check your internet. Confirm upload and download speeds, and how stable the connection has been over the past few months.
  2. Count your devices that use phone lines. Think beyond desk phones: fax, alarm panel, payment terminal, elevator or door entry.
  3. Map how calls should flow. Who answers first, what happens when the front desk is busy, what callers hear after hours and on holidays.
  4. Plan for outages. Decide where calls go if the office is offline, and whether you need a UPS or a backup internet connection.
  5. Check the cabling. Each phone location should have a working network jack, especially at the front desk and in private offices.
  6. Ask about your current numbers. Moving ("porting") your existing numbers to the new provider is normal; confirm the steps and timing.
  7. Ask about privacy. Recording, voicemail storage and access, as covered above.
  8. Schedule the cutover. Pick a quiet time, and have someone test incoming calls, transfers, voicemail and fax before patients start calling.

How Starcomm can help

We set up and support VoIP business phones for dental offices and other busy front desks across Mississauga, Toronto and the GTA. Because we also look after clinic networks, we check the parts that make VoIP sound good and stay up: the internet connection, traffic priority, cabling, battery backup and a sensible plan for outages. If a traditional line still makes sense for your fax or alarm, we will tell you.

If you are weighing VoIP against your current phone lines, call us at 905-816-9797 or contact us and we will talk it through in plain English.

Frequently asked questions

Can we keep our existing clinic phone number if we switch to VoIP?

In most cases, yes. Your number is transferred (ported) from your current carrier to the VoIP provider, and the new system is set up and tested before the switch happens.

Do we need new phones to use VoIP?

Usually you need VoIP-compatible desk phones, though some older systems can connect through an adapter. Your provider or IT company can tell you whether any of your current equipment can be reused.

Is VoIP cheaper than traditional phone lines for a dental office?

It often is, especially once you need several lines and features like an auto-attendant, but it depends on your call volume, number of phones and the plan you choose. Compare the full monthly cost, including any backup line or internet you decide to keep.

Can our staff answer the clinic phone from home?

Yes, many VoIP systems include a phone app or computer softphone that shows the clinic's number. If calls involve patient information, make sure staff use secured devices and private spaces.

Will our internet be too slow for VoIP and dental imaging at the same time?

Voice calls need relatively little bandwidth, but they need a steady connection. Setting the router to prioritize voice traffic usually keeps calls clear even while imaging or backups are running.

← All posts